I was given a Win8Phone recently. I suppose it may seem like looking a gift horse in the mouth to review it, but:
I must say, first off, that the Nokia Lumia has a lot of power compared to my other phone (and Android tablets), so I like the responsiveness using Twitter. The antenna is decent, so I can connect to hotspots, even at a bit of a distance. Also, this camera is a lot better than those on the three Android machines.
I’m finding the lack of functionality annoying. There isn’t any file access on the phone itself, although the ability to access it via Windows Explorer (when you plug the USB cable into a Windows 7 or 8 computer) is handy.
I find the huge buttons annoying, and the interface for most apps takes up a lot of space. This doesn’t seem to be adjustable: I can change the size of the font, but only for the content of an app, not for the frame or surround.
http://www.windowsphone.com/en-us/how-to/wp8 is useful: that’s how I found out how to switch between apps (hold down the back key and it gives you a set of
icons of running/active apps).
The range of apps is pathetic. Security aside (yes, I know a closed system is supposed to be more secure), you are stuck with a) Microsoft, or b) completely unknown software shops. You are stuck with Bing for search and maps: no Google, no Gmail. You are stuck with IE: no Firefox, Chrome, or Safari. Oh, sorry, yes you *can* get Firefox, Chrome, and Safari, but not from Mozilla, Google, or Apple: from developers you’ve never heard of. (Progpack, maker(s) of the Windows Phone store version of Safari, admits it is not the real Safari, it just “looks like it.”) You can’t get YouTube at all. No Pinterest, although there is a LinkedIn app from LinkedIn, and a Facebook app–from Microsoft.
It’s a bit hard to compare the interface. I’m comparing a Nokia Lumia 920 which has lots of power against a) the cheapest Android cell phone Bell had when I had to upgrade my account (ver 2.2), b) an Android 4.3 tablet which is really good but not quite “jacket” portable, and c) a Digital2 Android 4.1 mini-tablet which is probably meant for children and is *seriously* underpowered.
Don’t know whether this is the fault of Windows or the Nokia, but the battery indicators/indications are a major shortcoming. I have yet to see any indication that the phone has been fully charged. To get any accurate reading you have to go to the battery page under settings, and even that doesn’t tell you a heck of a lot. (Last night when I turned it off it said the battery was at 46% which should be good for 18 hours. After using it four times this morning for a total of about an hour screen time and two hours standby it is at 29%.)
(When I installed the Windows Phone app on my desktop, and did some file transfers while charging the phone through USB I found that the app has a battery level indicator on most pages, so that’s helpful.)