Spam hotspot
Posted on November 29th, 2005 by Aviram
Filed under: Commentary, Privacy, Spam, Phishing | 11 Comments »
Wardriving is practically extinct. It doesn’t make sense anymore to drive around looking for wireless hotspots, because that will be like using a complex GPS navigation system to find a starbucks. There’s no need to search for it - it’s right around the corner!
Wireless hotspots are everywhere – from the local coffee shops trying to compete with Starbucks by giving away free wifi, through the motels that found themselves forced to provide free Internet to their guests, to the community-sponsored free hotspot in places like Palo Alto. Google announced plans to cover Mountain View with free hotspots, and suddenly you don’t even have a driving license in order to wardrive.
This is all a good thing, of course, because it means I can enjoy Panera’s excellent soup without missing this week’s PBF cartoon. But there’s one drawback to this situation - we lose traceability.
Right now whenever someone decides to set up a new kiddie porn site, whether it’s on a zombie machine or a “bullet proof” hosting server, that machine has a unique IP address that is traceable to a person. Typically, only the ISP that provides the actual network connection will know who the person or organization behind that IP is, but that’s usually enough. If it’s a serious offense such as kiddie porn or phishing, coordination between the ISP’s and various security groups will get that machine shut down, and if necessary, prosecute the owner. Traceability is here in a sense that every IP identifies an ISP who can match {IP, timestamp} with a paying user. This will not be the case with free wifi hotspots.
With free wifi, there’s no authentication. Even if there were, as long as there’s no payment, the authentication is worthless.
Consider the following situation. I go to my favorite Café, order a tall Laté and post an anonymous note in a forum threatening to kill my teacher. In a typical scenario, the police could trace my IP from the forum logs, go to my ISP and ask for my address. But the IP that appears in the forum belongs to the wireless router used in the Café. Even in the unlikely situation where logs are kept, all the Café has is my internal address and my MAC address. I might even be there when the police comes – drinking my coffee and connecting to other web sites. They’ll have a hard time tracing my machine without triangulation hardware, and if I bought a new Wifi card at Fry’s, my MAC address will be different and then I really disappeared off the map.
Now consider this on a larger scale. Lets say I buy a mini-Mac, find my nearest Panera and place the mini-Mac some place where it won’t stand out (tape it on the rear restaurant walls near the garbage cans?) and use the wireless connection to send out kiddie porn pictures to a mailing list, or just plain spam. Even when somebody traces my machine back to Panera, it will be difficult to find the computer without sophisticated hardware. Even when it’s found, all I lose is the machine – it will never be traced back to me.
Easier and more reliable than using a zombie. Only a few hundred dollars to set up, no monthly fee (and no roaming charges, but I digress).
I’m not sure how to solve this problem, without completely shutting down free wifi access the way it is today – and I really wouldn’t want to see that happens. Maybe it’s one of the risks that arise when new technology comes into play.















Subscribe