Why Is Paid Responsible Disclosure So Damn Difficult?
June 29th, 2010 by xyberpix, Filed under: Apple, Commentary, Culture, Full Disclosure, Networking, Sec Tools
So I’ve been sitting on an Apple vulnerability for over a month now, and I’m really starting to realise that maybe just sending the details to the Full-Disclosure mailing list and Exploit-DB.com is the right way to go about disclosing vulnerabilities and exploits.
I initially contacted ZDI to see if they would be at all interested in buying the exploit off of me, as I spent a lot of time researching and finding this one, and I’d like to get something for my efforts. I am a firm believer in the No More Free Bugs movement, I understand and appreciate what ZDI are doing, but the fact that it took them just under a month to get back to me, is really not good enough to be very honest. If they don’t have the researchers, then advertise worldwide, instead of just US only. I know I for one, would be happy validating bugs all day, and this is the the type of work that can be remotely.
Yesterday I also submitted the same information to iDefense Labs Vulnerability Contributor Program (VCP), who claim to get back to me within 48 hours, so we’ll see how that goes. I will update this post as and I when I know more.
I also took the off chance of mailing Apple directly, and asking if they offer any rewards for vulnerabilities that have been found, and if so what they would be. I don’t have high hopes on Apple offering anything, but to be honest, I would prefer to disclose this one directly to Apple. They however have paid staff to do this work on a full time basis on all their products, so why aren’t they doing it properly, and I feel that anyone else finding bugs for them, should be compensated appropriately. However, I e-mailed them yesterday and recieved an automated response, so we see how long it takes them to respond to me as well.
This may end up being a rather long post, but let’s see. I’m also expecting to see quite a few interesting comments on this post as well, so come on people.
UPDATE 30/06/2010:
Received a response from iDefense last night,and a request for more info. So just over 24 hour response time, which is brilliant, I’m really impressed so far.
Recieved a response from Apple, and if I would like any reward (aside from credit for the find), then I was informed that I should go through ZDI or iDefense.
-
foobar
-
Andy
-
http://www.xyberpix.com xyberpix



